Our method
How We Review Supplements
The same process, applied to every product, written down so you can check our work.
The process
- Read the actual label. We work from the supplement facts panel, not the sales page. Where a product hides doses behind a “proprietary blend”, we say so — it is a meaningful limitation, because an undisclosed dose cannot be compared against any study.
- Identify the active ingredients. Fillers, flow agents and vitamins present at token amounts are separated from the ingredients doing the work.
- Search the literature for each one. We look for systematic reviews and randomised controlled trials first, and we check the dose used in the study against the dose in the product.
- Separate claims from evidence. Manufacturer statements are reported as manufacturer statements. Research findings are reported with their limitations: sample size, funding source, duration, population.
- Check safety. Known side effects, contraindications and interactions with common prescription medicines.
- Assess value. Cost per serving against the cost of the same ingredients bought individually, where that comparison is fair.
- Write the verdict. Who the product might suit, who should skip it, and what we would want to know before buying it ourselves.
What we do not do
- We do not test products in a laboratory. We have no analytical facility, so we cannot verify that a bottle contains what the label says. Where third-party testing certificates exist, we report them; where they do not, we note the absence.
- We do not run personal trials. One person taking a supplement for a month is an anecdote, not evidence, and presenting it as more would mislead you.
- We do not accept payment for favourable coverage. No brand has editorial input, approval rights or sight of a review before publication.
- We do not reuse a manufacturer’s own rating. A score on this site is ours, or there is no score.
How ratings work
Where we publish a rating out of five, it reflects four things in roughly equal measure: the strength of evidence behind the active ingredients, whether the doses are meaningful, transparency of labelling and third-party testing, and value for money. A product can be perfectly safe, pleasant to take and still score poorly, because the question we are answering is whether the evidence justifies the price.
Not every review carries a rating. When a product is too new, or the evidence too thin to judge fairly, we say that instead of inventing a number.
Updates and corrections
Formulations change and research moves. We revisit reviews when a formula is reformulated, when significant new evidence is published, or when a reader tells us something is wrong. Updated reviews carry a modified date.
If you think we have made an error, tell us. We would rather be corrected than be wrong.